2026-06-17T09:43:23  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> Could someone have a look at why https://events.opensuse.org/conferences/oSC26/schedule.xml reports 403 when the request comes from github actions?
2026-06-17T09:43:25  <matrix-o-o>  https://github.com/Wilm0r/giggity/actions/runs/27679971126/job/81864670139?pr=507#step:10:302
2026-06-17T10:19:44  <acidsys> hi Aylen, the same works from other networks? any idea which user-agent that is requesting with?
2026-06-17T10:26:31  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> acidsys I guess something starting with "python-urllib3"
2026-06-17T10:26:54  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> acidsys The code is something like this:
2026-06-17T10:27:53  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> acidsys The code is something like this:
2026-06-17T10:28:11  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> As you can see, it works fine for me locally, so it looks like as if the source network from github actions is the problem
2026-06-17T10:33:00  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> It should be something starting with "python-urllib3"
2026-06-17T10:35:20  <acidsys> do you have a way to run this pipeline with more output to show the response headers/body? there is no 403 configured for networks: https://github.com/openSUSE/heroes-salt/blob/2e7296291fea394ba83af5643db34ece30d18556/pillar/cluster/atlas/init.sls#L106, and it could be from a different machine
2026-06-17T10:36:52  <acidsys> and urllib should be a fine useragent :)
2026-06-17T13:00:09  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> I did some more checks and the problem is the url to the normal website:
2026-06-17T13:00:25  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> > > > import requests; requests.get("https://events.opensuse.org/conferences/oSC26/";)
2026-06-17T13:00:25  <matrix-o-o> > > >  <Response [403]>
2026-06-17T13:00:36  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> >>> import requests; requests.get(" https://events.opensuse.org/conferences/oSC26/" ;)
2026-06-17T13:00:36  <matrix-o-o> <Response [403]>
2026-06-17T13:04:48  <acidsys> well that is expected, only .xml is exmpeted
2026-06-17T13:05:00  <acidsys> exempt *
2026-06-17T13:06:50  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> hm - it works with curl, but not with requests, even when I set the user-agent to curl.
2026-06-17T13:06:50  <matrix-o-o>  But anyways: could you add an exception, so we can get the openSUSE conference listed in the giggity app?
2026-06-17T13:07:30  <acidsys> there is no difference with those user agents
2026-06-17T13:07:53  <acidsys> why does it need to request the main path, it should be sufficient to query the api or the xml endpoint ?
2026-06-17T13:19:02  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> It checks that all the URLs listed in the json definition are reachable
2026-06-17T13:20:32  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> And the JSON definition contains a list of links that are shown in the menu of the app, so that the user can directly access e.g. the website, a map, a wiki, etc
2026-06-17T13:20:44  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> https://github.com/Wilm0r/giggity/pull/507/changes
2026-06-17T13:31:26  <acidsys> ah I understand, but that's not great, removing protection from the main path for this third party "health check"
2026-06-17T13:33:55  <acidsys> it's odd the error message would report the 403 on the .xml file though if you say it in reality is coming from the main path
2026-06-17T13:39:57  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> It doesn't report it for the XML url, but the output is a bit confusing
2026-06-17T13:40:37  <acidsys> what do you mean it doesn't report it, reading your link it says exactly this
2026-06-17T13:40:39  <acidsys> Error: URL should reference an XML or an ICS file: https://events.opensuse.org/conferences/oSC26/schedule.xml
2026-06-17T13:40:41  <acidsys> Error: Link "Website" appears broken: HTTP 403 Forbidden
2026-06-17T13:41:23  <acidsys> but now I understand it says the "Link Website" is your metadata link, and separate from the "url should reference ..."
2026-06-17T13:43:09  <acidsys> hm interesting, in your last run without the metadata, you only get it for the xml. but without a http error
2026-06-17T13:44:25  <matrix-o-o> <Aylen> yes - because the check that was recently added, looks at the begin of the file for a "<?xml", but we don't have that
2026-06-17T13:44:27  <acidsys> the tools/menu-ci.py => validate_entry(), could you try to reproduce this locally or add some print statements
2026-06-17T13:44:40  <acidsys> :) same thought